BacktestTradingView Bar Replay vs A-Backtest
TradingView's replay mode is the feature that taught many traders what bar replay is. But it is a charting feature, not a backtesting workflow: full replay depth belongs to paid plans, and there is no realistic order simulation or journal attached. A-Backtest is built the other way around — replay is the core, and everything a manual backtest needs is wrapped around it, free.
Try A-Backtest freeSide by side
| A-Backtest | TradingView bar replay | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free — all features | Replay included, but full depth/intraday tied to paid plans |
| Purpose | Dedicated manual backtesting simulator | Chart review feature inside a charting platform |
| Order simulation | Orders with SL/TP, gap-aware fills, spread & commission | No full trade simulation in replay |
| Position sizing | Risk-% based lot calculation | Manual |
| Prop-firm challenge rules | Yes — FTMO-style targets, daily loss, max DD | No |
| Trade journal & stats | Built-in: win rate, R-multiples, drawdown, per-setup | No |
| Blind / random-start testing | Yes — hidden random start date | No |
| Markets | Forex, gold & silver, crypto, US indices | Depends on plan and data subscriptions |
TradingView details as of August 2026 — their plans evolve, so check tradingview.com. TradingView remains an excellent charting platform; this comparison is only about replay backtesting.
Different tools for different jobs
If you live in TradingView for analysis, keep doing that — it is superb charting. But when you want to test a strategy over hundreds of trades with honest fills, costs and statistics, a purpose-built simulator saves you from spreadsheet bookkeeping and wishful fills. A-Backtest gives you that workflow in the browser, free.
What 'realistic' means here
Backtests lie when fills are generous. A-Backtest simulates spread and commission, fills stops and targets with gap awareness, sizes positions from your risk percentage, and can hide the date so you cannot cheat by remembering the chart. The journal then tells you the truth about your win rate and drawdown.
Frequently asked questions
Is A-Backtest a replacement for TradingView?
No — it replaces the backtesting part, not the charting platform. Many users analyse on TradingView and run their replay backtests on A-Backtest.
Does TradingView replay let me place simulated orders?
Replay mode is primarily chart playback; it does not provide the full order-simulation, risk-sizing and journaling workflow a manual backtest needs. That gap is exactly what A-Backtest fills, for free.
Can I use both together?
Absolutely — the tools complement each other. Chart and share ideas on TradingView; measure your edge candle by candle on A-Backtest.
Measure your edge, not your memory
Free bar-replay backtesting with real orders and stats. Start in one minute.
Start free